A broadly-recognized social network users’ bill of rights will be a huge step forward for online freedom and privacy. For me, and hundreds of millions of others, sites like Facebook, Twitter, tribe.net, and free-association are how I stay in touch with friends and family. As Voces Contra Las FARC, Barack Obama, #iranelection, and hundreds of other campaigns have shown, social network sites are also vital for political activism. And yet, today we the users of the sites have only minimal rights.
— me, in It’s time for a Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights, June 2010
Today’s SXSW panel Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights: You Decide is a great chance to rekindle the energy on the #billofrights (as we like to say on Twitter).  Panelists Christina Gagnier, Lisa Borodkin, and Jack Lerner all spoke at last year’s ACM Computers, Freedom, and Privacy conference last year when we crafted the document.* Alex Howard of O’Reilly joins them. Cool! Check out the #snubor hashtag!
I like what CFP has done because I think they’ve covered all the bases, and they’ve done it with language that 95 percent of Web users can understand.
— Terry Sweeney, A Manifesto in the Name of Privacy, Internet Evolution
Since last June, the revolutions in Tunisia and Egypt have helped highlight the importance of social networks for political purposes, the Commerce Department has called for an online Privacy Bill of Rights — and ongoing news stories like A Chinese Activist and Mark Zuckerberg’s Dog continue to spotlight many social network sites’ challenges with free speech, and pseudonymity. With this year’s CFP scheduled for Washington DC in mid-June, now’s a perfect time to get serious about organizing.
Here’s a few ideas:
- get social network sites to adopt the concept of a Bill of Rights for their users and as many of the individual rights as they’re comfortable with.  Some of the specific rights are contentious — for example, Facebook objected to in their response last summer. But more positively, Facebook’s current “user rights and responsibilities” document already covers many of these rights, and it would be great to have even partial support from them. And sites like Twitter, tribe.net, and emerging companies that are trying to emphasize different values may be willing to go even farther.
- work with politicians in the US and elsewhere who are looking at protecting online, and encourage them to adopt the bill of rights framework and our specific language. There’s a bit of “carrot and stick” combining this and the previous bullet: the threat of legislation is great both for encouraging self-regulation and getting startups to look for a potential future strategic advantage by adopting strong user rights from the beginning.
- encourage broad participation to highlight where there’s consensus. Currently, there are a couple of ways to weigh in: the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights site allows you to vote on the individual rights, and you can also vote for or against the entire bill via Twitter. It would be great to have additional voting on other social network sites like Facebook, MySpace, Reddit to give the citizens of those “countries” a voice.
- collaborate with with groups like the Global Network Initiative, the Internet Rights and Principles Coalition, the Social Charter, and the Association for Progressive Communications that support similar principles
- follow Gabrielle Pohl’s lead and translate into multiple languages to build awareness globally.
- take a more active approach with media outreach to call more attention to the campaign. #privchat, the weekly Twitter chat sponsored by Center for Democracy and Technology and Privacy Camp, is natural hub for the discussion.
On Quora Lisa Borodkin commented
Much de facto policy is now made by the free market. I see a need for users to organize and speak somehow as a quantifiable a group to give feedback to Facebook, Google and other well-intentioned social networking sites when the sites do things on erroneous premises of what users want.
Indeed. And we, the users, are doing just that. Please join us!
jon
Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights: You Decide is scheduled for 3:30 p.m. Austin time (1:30 p.m Pacific, 4:30 p.m. Eastern) on Friday, March 11. I’m not sure whether video will be streamed, but in any case there will certainly be active discussion on Twitter. See you on the #snubor hashtag!
* Lisa and Jack had also written We, the users, which along with bills of rights by Kurt Opsahl of EFF and Mark Sullivan of PC World helped inspire the grassroots drafting process.
Liminal states :: #snubor at #sxswi: The Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights panel at South by Southwest | 11-Mar-11 at 4:38 pm | Permalink
[…] Bill of Rights site, and you can also vote for or against the entire bill via Twitter. My post here has some thoughts, and there are also some questions on Quora (1, 2). We’ll propose at […]
IdentityBlog - Digital Identity, Privacy, and the Internet's Missing Identity Layer | 15-Mar-11 at 6:46 am | Permalink
[…] do the organizers want to go next? Jon Pincus writes: Here’s a few […]
Kim Cameron | 15-Mar-11 at 6:49 am | Permalink
Wonderful initiative Jon!
While I support all other aspects of the Bill, I do think it is a mistake to mandate that ALL communities MUST support pseudonymity or be in violation of the Bill… In all other respects, the Bill is consistent with the Laws of Identity. However the Laws envisaged a continuum of approaches to identification, and argued that all have their place for different purposes. I think this is much closer to the mark and Right 12 should be amended. The fundamental point is that we must have the RIGHT to form and participate in communities that DO choose to support pseudonymity. This doesn’t mean we ONLY have the right to participate in such communities
See: http://www.identityblog.com/?p=1172
jon | 15-Mar-11 at 10:54 am | Permalink
Thanks for blogging about it, Kim — and thanks for the comment!
Once again, right #12 proves controversial. The way I look at it, unless a community provides pseudonymity, people like whistleblowers, domestic violence victims, political dissidents, closeted LGBTQs and so on are severely disadvantaged. See for example this quote from CFP 2009 co-chair Cindy Southworth of the National Network to End Domestic Violence:
Without pseudonymity, important classes of people can’t participate. if Is it okay for the corporations owning a site to institutionalize that kind of discrimination — or for governments to mandate it?
PS: I tried to leave this comment on Kim’s blog too, but no joy. I hate software
Liminal states :: Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights: the voting so far | 23-Mar-11 at 10:12 am | Permalink
[…] 89% or higher. The one exception: the right to self-define, currently at about 65%. As I said in a comment on the earlier thread, this right is vital for people like whistleblowers, domestic violence […]
http://Lonjack7756959988.Wikidot.com/ | 04-Dec-19 at 12:20 am | Permalink
http://Lonjack7756959988.Wikidot.com/
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Store Jewelry | 04-Dec-19 at 11:41 pm | Permalink
Store Jewelry
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
www.srecruiters.com | 22-Dec-19 at 12:46 am | Permalink
http://www.srecruiters.com
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Backcountrylandtrust.org | 22-Dec-19 at 10:02 pm | Permalink
Backcountrylandtrust.org
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
porn Hub Spanking | 24-Dec-19 at 6:26 pm | Permalink
porn Hub Spanking
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
how to Frugally stage a Home | 24-Dec-19 at 9:33 pm | Permalink
how to Frugally stage a Home
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
completely repair Cabinets | 26-Dec-19 at 5:09 am | Permalink
completely repair Cabinets
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Http://Www.Kinky-Fetish-Phonesex.Info/ | 01-Jan-20 at 5:58 am | Permalink
http://Www.Kinky-Fetish-Phonesex.Info/
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Formatium blog article | 03-Jan-20 at 6:47 am | Permalink
Formatium blog article
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Country Style Kitchen | 03-Jan-20 at 8:07 pm | Permalink
Country Style Kitchen
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Cabinets inside | 12-Jan-20 at 11:11 pm | Permalink
Cabinets inside
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Outdated kitchen cabinets | 17-Jan-20 at 3:40 am | Permalink
Outdated kitchen cabinets
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Qq online | 23-Jan-20 at 7:30 pm | Permalink
Qq online
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
what is the best hair growth products at walmart | 27-Jan-20 at 11:57 pm | Permalink
what is the best hair growth products at walmart
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Dominoqq Online | 28-Jan-20 at 5:10 pm | Permalink
Dominoqq Online
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
kitchen Walls | 30-Jan-20 at 4:35 am | Permalink
kitchen Walls
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Sell House To Investor Cornelius | 02-Feb-20 at 6:08 pm | Permalink
Sell House To Investor Cornelius
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
leads for commercial roofing companies | 05-Feb-20 at 5:24 pm | Permalink
leads for commercial roofing companies
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Ecu Repair Training | 07-Feb-20 at 1:06 pm | Permalink
Ecu Repair Training
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Ecu Simulator | 07-Feb-20 at 2:45 pm | Permalink
Ecu Simulator
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
model 3 | 07-Feb-20 at 11:05 pm | Permalink
model 3
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
botox for neck wrinkles | 09-Feb-20 at 2:47 am | Permalink
botox for neck wrinkles
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Www.Servertoplist.Com | 10-Feb-20 at 8:48 am | Permalink
http://Www.Servertoplist.Com
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
waar kan Ik het best een fotobooth Huren | 15-Feb-20 at 6:28 am | Permalink
waar kan Ik het best een fotobooth Huren
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
wat krijg ik allemaal bij een foto Booth huren | 15-Feb-20 at 11:46 am | Permalink
wat krijg ik allemaal bij een foto Booth huren
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Simplish App | 16-Feb-20 at 3:07 am | Permalink
Simplish App
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
guest posting service | 18-Feb-20 at 1:00 am | Permalink
guest posting service
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
tiny home kitchen appliance sets | 18-Feb-20 at 5:37 pm | Permalink
tiny home kitchen appliance sets
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
auto body painting inglewood ca | 18-Feb-20 at 6:49 pm | Permalink
auto body painting inglewood ca
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
roof installation Bosque Farms | 19-Feb-20 at 4:04 am | Permalink
roof installation Bosque Farms
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
depression fix | 24-Feb-20 at 12:14 pm | Permalink
depression fix
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
BMW Egypt | 28-Feb-20 at 2:03 am | Permalink
BMW Egypt
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
kitchen cabinet refinisher | 02-Mar-20 at 10:37 pm | Permalink
kitchen cabinet refinisher
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Research Waterless Cookware | 04-Mar-20 at 5:17 am | Permalink
Research Waterless Cookware
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?
Carbamide Peroxide Teeth Whitening | 26-Mar-20 at 3:22 pm | Permalink
Carbamide Peroxide Teeth Whitening
Liminal states :: What next for the Social Network Users’ Bill of Rights?